Mock First-Year Player Draft

James Anderson enlists the help of three other dynasty rankers to do a mock first-year player draft that goes 24 players deep, in which James ends up with Pirates righty Paul Skenes with the third overall pick.
Mock First-Year Player Draft
SPECIAL OFFER

Get 25% OFF

Dominate your NFL Draft this season with limited time offer. Use promo code PURPLE
PROMO CODE PURPLE

On this week's RotoWire Prospect Podcast, I was joined by three great dynasty analysts (Jesse Roche, Eric Cross and Chris Clegg) for a six-round mock first-year player draft, featuring only players selected in this year's MLB Draft.

I've already released my super early top 50 rankings/article, if you want to read my initial analysis on these players. 

This seems like a year with less consensus than ever after the top five players, so I thought this mock would be particularly helpful, as you've got four different biases shaping the order that these FYPD prospects are valued at this moment. As I said on my recent appearance on Chris Welsh's podcast, Prospect One, the five players who went sixth through 10th in the real draft (Jacob Wilson, Rhett Lowder, Blake Mitchell, Chase Dollander, Noble Meyer) will rarely go in the top 10 of a FYPD, so it's really a get your guy type of class. Everyone seems to have different preferences among the high school shortstops, college and high school pitchers, and even the strength of the class -- the college hitters.

Here are the results from the mock draft. Please follow and support the work of Eric Cross, Jesse Roche and Chris Clegg, who were gracious enough to participate with me.

PickDrafterPlayerAgePositionTeam
1.1CrossDylan Crews21OFWAS
1.2RocheWyatt Langford21OFTEX
1.3AndersonPaul Skenes21RHPPIT
1.4CleggWalker Jenkins18OFMIN
2.5CleggChase Davis21OFSTL
2.6AndersonMax Clark18OFDET
2.7RocheMatt Shaw212B/3BCHC
2.8CrossArjun Nimmala17SS/3BTOR
3.9CrossBrock Wilken213B/1BMIL
3.10RocheBrayden Taylor213B/SSTB
3.11AndersonTommy Troy212B/3B/OFARI
3.12CleggNoble Meyer18RHPMIA
4.13CleggAidan Miller193BPHI
4.14AndersonHurston Waldrep21RHPATL
4.15RocheNolan Schanuel211BLAA
4.16CrossEnrique Bradfield21OFBAL
5.17CrossRhett Lowder21RHPCIN
5.18RocheBrice Matthews21OF/2B/SSHOU
5.19AndersonSammy Stafura18SSCIN
5.20CleggColin Houck183B/SSNYM
6.21CleggNazzan Zanetello18SS/OF/3BBOS
6.22AndersonKemp Alderman20OF/C/1BMIA
6.23RocheWalker Martin193B/SSSF
6.24CrossJack Hurley21OFARI

On this week's RotoWire Prospect Podcast, I was joined by three great dynasty analysts (Jesse Roche, Eric Cross and Chris Clegg) for a six-round mock first-year player draft, featuring only players selected in this year's MLB Draft.

I've already released my super early top 50 rankings/article, if you want to read my initial analysis on these players. 

This seems like a year with less consensus than ever after the top five players, so I thought this mock would be particularly helpful, as you've got four different biases shaping the order that these FYPD prospects are valued at this moment. As I said on my recent appearance on Chris Welsh's podcast, Prospect One, the five players who went sixth through 10th in the real draft (Jacob Wilson, Rhett Lowder, Blake Mitchell, Chase Dollander, Noble Meyer) will rarely go in the top 10 of a FYPD, so it's really a get your guy type of class. Everyone seems to have different preferences among the high school shortstops, college and high school pitchers, and even the strength of the class -- the college hitters.

Here are the results from the mock draft. Please follow and support the work of Eric Cross, Jesse Roche and Chris Clegg, who were gracious enough to participate with me.

PickDrafterPlayerAgePositionTeam
1.1CrossDylan Crews21OFWAS
1.2RocheWyatt Langford21OFTEX
1.3AndersonPaul Skenes21RHPPIT
1.4CleggWalker Jenkins18OFMIN
2.5CleggChase Davis21OFSTL
2.6AndersonMax Clark18OFDET
2.7RocheMatt Shaw212B/3BCHC
2.8CrossArjun Nimmala17SS/3BTOR
3.9CrossBrock Wilken213B/1BMIL
3.10RocheBrayden Taylor213B/SSTB
3.11AndersonTommy Troy212B/3B/OFARI
3.12CleggNoble Meyer18RHPMIA
4.13CleggAidan Miller193BPHI
4.14AndersonHurston Waldrep21RHPATL
4.15RocheNolan Schanuel211BLAA
4.16CrossEnrique Bradfield21OFBAL
5.17CrossRhett Lowder21RHPCIN
5.18RocheBrice Matthews21OF/2B/SSHOU
5.19AndersonSammy Stafura18SSCIN
5.20CleggColin Houck183B/SSNYM
6.21CleggNazzan Zanetello18SS/OF/3BBOS
6.22AndersonKemp Alderman20OF/C/1BMIA
6.23RocheWalker Martin193B/SSSF
6.24CrossJack Hurley21OFARI

Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
James Anderson is RotoWire's Lead Prospect Analyst, Assistant Baseball Editor, and co-host of Farm Fridays on Sirius/XM radio and the RotoWire Prospect Podcast.
RotoWire Logo

Continue the Conversation

Join the RotoWire Discord group to hear from our experts and other MLB fans.

Top News

Tools

MLB Draft Kit Logo

MLB Draft Kit

Fantasy Tools

Don’t miss a beat. Check out our 2025 MLB Fantasy Baseball rankings.