NFL Week 9 Player Props: Today's Best Odds, Prop Bets and Predictions

Compare Week 9 NFL Player Props to find the best odds on prop bets for this weekend's slate of games. 

Each table contains every player prop market across the most popular sports betting apps. We created these prop tables because we wanted a bird's-eye view of prices across the board so that we can hunt for value. 

Every sportsbook may not offer a market for every prop, but you can filter by sportsbook or by searching for a specific player to quickly find answers before you place your bet. Make sure you grab an offer like the bet365 bonus code to ensure you make the most out of each bet. 

Best NFL Player Props Week 9

While you can (and should) compare all player prop markets using RotoWire's tool below, I want to highlight some of the best NFL player prop bets for Week 9. Here are my four favorite Week 9 player props. 

Best BetMGM NFL Player Props Week 9

BetMGM Sportsbook provides all odds in this section. Use a BetMGM Sportsbook promo to maximize your player props. 

J.J. McCarthy – Completions: UNDER 19.5 (-135) 

J.J. McCarthy flashed big-time talent in one of the eight quarters he's played this season. But the other seven haven't exactly been pretty. He's shown no ability to run Kevin O'Connell's offense, and I don't think they're going to ask him to do too much in his return. McCarthy attempted 21 passes or fewer in both of his starts this season, topping out at 13 completions in Week 1. This total is nearly as high as his average attempts. Meanwhile, the Bears' defense has quietly rounded into form, sitting ninth in EPA per play since Week 4. I think Minnesota will try to lean on Aaron Jones and Jordan Mason, as KOC tries to limit the burden on his second-year QB. If you're a little scared off by the -135 juice, you could consider going under 18.5 at FanDuel or DraftKings, as both lines are a lot closer to even odds. 

Best DraftKings NFL Player Props Week 9

DraftKings Sportsbook provides all odds in this section. Use a DraftKings Sportsbook promo to maximize your player props. 

Tyler Shough – Passing Yards: UNDER 186.5 (-115)

We'll double-dip on unders for young QBs here. This is a terrible spot for a rookie QB to make his starting debut, as the Rams have quietly become one of the league's best defenses. LA is second in the league in EPA per play, dropback EPA, and they're fifth in dropback success rate. They've allowed the seventh-fewest passing yards so far, forcing a pressure at the eighth-highest rate in the league. That's a problem for Shough, who will be playing behind the league's ninth-worst pass-blocking unit, per PFF. I'm predicting a rough debut for Shough, who completed 17-of-30 passes for 128 yards and an INT in relief of Rattler last week. 

Best FanDuel NFL Player Props Week 9

FanDuel Sportsbook provides all odds in this section. Use a FanDuel Sportsbook promo to maximize your player props. 

Rashee Rice – Receptions: OVER 6.5 (-122) 

Rashee Rice has become the focal point of this offense since his Week 7 return. He only ran 19 routes in that game, turning 10 targets into seven receptions. He played a full complement of snaps in Week 8, catching all nine of his targets for 93 yards and a score. He even added another two carries for 12 yards. The point is clear: Kansas City wants the ball in his hands. Rice caught seven passes in his lone regular-season game against Buffalo in 2023, and I'm betting he tops that here in Week 9. 

Compare All NFL Player Props: Week 9