Farm Futures: Outfield Tiers, Top 400 Update

Farm Futures: Outfield Tiers, Top 400 Update

This article is part of our Farm Futures series.

TOP 400 UPDATE

Before getting to the outfield prospect tiers for dynasty leagues, I wanted to touch briefly on last week's update to the top 400 prospect rankings

The majority of the movement was to the back half of the rankings and it reflected all the work I did with the divisional prospect articles, in which I wrote about 750 total prospects. I think the biggest theme from this update was that I wanted to stress upside in that 200-400 range. Of course, I stress upside throughout the whole top 400, but when I roster prospects in dynasty leagues, I'm only chasing upside in those final prospect spots. This means that the likely No. 4/5 starters got bumped off the list in favor of teenagers who may never amount to anything. You should be churning your last few prospect spots pretty regularly. I'd rather roster a guy like Estiven Machado or Richi Gonzalez and then cut them in July if they're not hitting than roster a starting pitcher for several years who is likely to pitch in a big-league rotation, but is unlikely to ever be a player who is sought after in mixed leagues. Even in 20-team dynasty leagues, you can often pick up a David Bote or John Means off waivers, so why roster the prospect version of that player? 

It's also important to stress where the tiers are in the top 400. The gap between a player I have at No. 3 (Julio Rodriguez)

TOP 400 UPDATE

Before getting to the outfield prospect tiers for dynasty leagues, I wanted to touch briefly on last week's update to the top 400 prospect rankings

The majority of the movement was to the back half of the rankings and it reflected all the work I did with the divisional prospect articles, in which I wrote about 750 total prospects. I think the biggest theme from this update was that I wanted to stress upside in that 200-400 range. Of course, I stress upside throughout the whole top 400, but when I roster prospects in dynasty leagues, I'm only chasing upside in those final prospect spots. This means that the likely No. 4/5 starters got bumped off the list in favor of teenagers who may never amount to anything. You should be churning your last few prospect spots pretty regularly. I'd rather roster a guy like Estiven Machado or Richi Gonzalez and then cut them in July if they're not hitting than roster a starting pitcher for several years who is likely to pitch in a big-league rotation, but is unlikely to ever be a player who is sought after in mixed leagues. Even in 20-team dynasty leagues, you can often pick up a David Bote or John Means off waivers, so why roster the prospect version of that player? 

It's also important to stress where the tiers are in the top 400. The gap between a player I have at No. 3 (Julio Rodriguez) and No. 20 (Matt Manning) is massive, but the gap between a player I have at No. 200 (Eduardo Garcia) and No. 350 (Connor Scott) isn't that big at all. Think of the back half of the rankings as a playground. You can check out all of these players and pick the ones you like most, you shouldn't view the rankings as super rigid in that range. I'm happy to answer any questions about the top 400 update in the comments of this article.

OUTFIELD TIERS

If you want in-depth analysis on these guys, I wrote the outlooks for every single guy in the seven tiers, although some of the honorable mention guys didn't get outlooks.

TIER ONE

1. Julio Rodriguez, Mariners

I have Wander Franco in his own tier and Gavin Lux and Rodriguez in their own tier in the overall rankings. It's largely due to the fact I think Lux and Rodriguez are extremely safe and have very high ceilings. Rodriguez is good enough to be a No. 1 overall prospect, but I don't know if he'll get that chance, as he could end up beating Franco to the majors.

TIER TWO

2. Jo Adell, Angels

3. Luis Robert, White Sox

4. Dylan Carlson, Cardinals

5. Jasson Dominguez, Yankees

6. Drew Waters, Braves

7. Kristian Robinson, Diamondbacks

8. Marco Luciano, Giants

9. Jarred Kelenic, Mariners

The prospects from 4-14 on the top 400 are all in the same tier. Any of them could emerge as the best of the bunch and I wouldn't be surprised. Luciano probably has the lowest stolen-base upside of this bunch, but he also might end up with the most raw power by the time he reaches the majors. Robert and Dominguez are the only guys who I think could log a 30-steal season. Luciano's defensive home is uncertain, but I'm betting on him ending up in the outfield.

TIER THREE

10. Corbin Carroll, Diamondbacks

Carroll is on an island as the only outfielder in the 15-37 range of the top 400. Alex Kirilloff could have OF eligibility some years, but I put him in the First Base Tiers. Carroll's leadoff-hitter skills and 30-steal potential are obvious, but don't sleep on his power. I think he'll surprise a lot of people, getting to 20-25 homer pop at peak.

TIER FOUR

11. Erick Pena, Royals

12. Sam Hilliard, Rockies

13. Cristian Pache, Braves

14. Riley Greene, Tigers

15. Hunter Bishop, Giants

16. Luis Matos, Giants

17. Josh Lowe, Rays

18. Alek Thomas, Diamondbacks

19. Brennen Davis, Cubs

I would argue that Pache has the lowest fantasy ceiling in this tier, but there is no denying he is by far the most likely to have a long big-league career, due to his elite defense in center field. Highest ceilings: Pena, Matos, Bishop, Hilliard, Lowe.

TIER FIVE

20. Luis Rodriguez, Dodgers

21. Oneil Cruz, Pirates

22. Brandon Marsh, Angels

23. George Valera, Indians

24. Austin Hays, Orioles

25. JJ Bleday, Marlins

26. Jared Oliva, Pirates

27. Heliot Ramos, Giants

28. Trevor Larnach, Twins

Marsh and Oliva are the only guys in this tier who I expect to steal double-digit bases — Marsh could steal 20, Oliva could steal 25-30. Rodriguez, Marsh and Bleday have the best hit tool projections, Rodriguez, Cruz, Valera, Ramos, Larnach have the best raw power projections. Obviously Cruz is still playing shortstop for now, but if I had to bet on where he will end up, I'd pick right field.

TIER SIX

29. Monte Harrison, Marlins

30. Alexander Canario, Giants

31. Kameron Misner, Marlins

32. Taylor Trammell, Padres

33. Misael Urbina, Twins

34. Jake Fraley, Mariners

35. Greg Jones, Rays

36. Hedbert Perez, Brewers

37. Khalil Lee, Royals

Harrison, Trammell, Fraley and Lee are all fairly close to the majors and all have at least 20-steal upside with varying degrees of power and hit tool concerns. Urbina and Perez are the least flawed, but also the furthest away. Canario, Misner and Jones have at least one loud tool with some strikeout concerns.

TIER SEVEN

38. Ryan Mountcastle, Orioles

39. Yusniel Diaz, Orioles

40. Daniel Johnson, Nationals

41. Jordyn Adams, Angels

42. Benyamin Bailey, White Sox

43. Travis Swaggerty, Pirates

44. Alexfri Planez, Indians

Mountcastle, Diaz and Johnson are close to big-league ready, but their upside isn't very exciting. Adams and Swaggerty have 20-plus steal upside but it's unclear whether they will hit enough to be everyday big leaguers. Bailey and Planez are super tooled up and a long ways away.

Honorable Mention: Jesus Sanchez, Leody Taveras, Hudson Head, Gilberto Jimenez, Daz Cameron, DJ Peters, Alexander Ramirez, Jhon Torres, Edward Olivares, Canaan Smith, Heriberto Hernandez, Wilderd Patino, Jeferson Espinal, Will Benson, Brenton Doyle, Richi Gonzalez, Peyton Burdick, Lolo Sanchez, Kyle Isbel, Michael Harris, Jeremy De La Rosa, Jonatan Clase

Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

Get Instant Access To This Article Get Access To This Article
RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only MLB Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire MLB fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
James Anderson
James Anderson is RotoWire's Lead Prospect Analyst, Assistant Baseball Editor, and co-host of Farm Fridays on Sirius/XM radio and the RotoWire Prospect Podcast.
The Z Files: My New Approach to the Roundtable Rankings
The Z Files: My New Approach to the Roundtable Rankings
Farm Futures: Rookie Outfielder Rankings
Farm Futures: Rookie Outfielder Rankings
Offseason Deep Dives: Reynaldo Lopez
Offseason Deep Dives: Reynaldo Lopez
Offseason Deep Dives: Hunter Greene
Offseason Deep Dives: Hunter Greene