The younger Naylor is regarded far more for his glove than his bat -- his .195 batting average was the lowest among all players with at least 400 plate appearances last season. To his credit, Naylor improved his walk rate to double digits last season, which helped his OBP, though he was still well below league average by most offensive measures. The fact that he has accumulated 3.1 fWAR for Cleveland over the last two seasons speaks volumes of his defense, because he has been a significant negative at the plate. Thanks to the steady playing time afforded by his defense, Naylor has reached double-digit homers each of the last three years, providing a modicum of fantasy value. The low average is tough to stomach, but the volume keeps Naylor in the mix as a low-end second catcher entering 2026. Read Past Outlooks