Hayes, now entering his age-29 season, remains an all-world defender at third base. However, he is near the opposite end of the spectrum offensively. His .306 SLG was the lowest among qualified hitters in 2025, while his .595 OPS was second lowest. After signing Hayes to an eight-year, $70 million extension in 2022, the Pirates eventually developed buyer's remorse, trading him to Cincinnati at the deadline. While Hayes' offensive numbers improved slightly after the move, he still managed just a .656 OPS and three homers in 178 regular-season PA with the Reds. Thanks to his defense, he has racked up an impressive 11.6 fWAR in six major-league seasons. The past two seasons have been especially difficult for him at the dish, though Hayes has at least reached double-digit steals each of the last four years. Cincinnati figures to keep him at the hot corner to begin 2026, health permitting. Read Past Outlooks