RotoWire 200: Overall Composite Rankings

RotoWire 200: Overall Composite Rankings

This article is part of our A Look at the Free Agent Market series.

To sign up for a free 10-day trial to RotoWire click here.


These are the individual and composite ratings of four RotoWire NFL Writers as of August 12. Assume a standard 12 or 14-team league. Kickers and defenses were not ranked.

Mark StopaChris LissKevin PayneLuke HooverOverall AVG
1Adrian PetersonAdrian PetersonAdrian PetersonAdrian PetersonAdrian Peterson1.00
2C.J. SpillerDoug MartinArian FosterDoug MartinDoug Martin3.50
3Calvin JohnsonC.J. SpillerCalvin JohnsonArian FosterC.J. Spiller4.25
4Marshawn LynchTrent RichardsonJamaal CharlesJamaal CharlesArian Foster4.50
5Doug MartinCalvin JohnsonDoug MartinMarshawn LynchCalvin Johnson4.75
6Jamaal CharlesArian FosterC.J. SpillerC.J. SpillerJamaal Charles6.50
7Arian FosterRay RiceRay RiceTrent RichardsonMarshawn Lynch6.75
8LeSean McCoyLeSean McCoyMarshawn LynchCalvin JohnsonRay Rice9.00
9Dez BryantDez BryantAlfred MorrisLeSean McCoyLeSean McCoy9.50
10Alfred MorrisMarshawn LynchTrent RichardsonRay RiceTrent Richardson11.00
11Trent RichardsonA.J. GreenJimmy GrahamAlfred MorrisAlfred Morris11.50
12Ray RiceJamaal CharlesBrandon MarshallDez BryantDez Bryant13.75
13Jimmy GrahamDemaryius ThomasLeSean McCoyDrew BreesBrandon Marshall15.75
14A.J. GreenMaurice Jones-DrewA.J. GreenAaron RodgersJimmy Graham16.00
15Brandon MarshallJulio JonesMaurice Jones-DrewChris JohnsonA.J. Green16.00
16Julio JonesAlfred MorrisAaron RodgersPeyton ManningDemaryius Thomas17.75
17Matt ForteChris JohnsonDemaryius
To sign up for a free 10-day trial to RotoWire click here.


These are the individual and composite ratings of four RotoWire NFL Writers as of August 12. Assume a standard 12 or 14-team league. Kickers and defenses were not ranked.

Mark StopaChris LissKevin PayneLuke HooverOverall AVG
1Adrian PetersonAdrian PetersonAdrian PetersonAdrian PetersonAdrian Peterson1.00
2C.J. SpillerDoug MartinArian FosterDoug MartinDoug Martin3.50
3Calvin JohnsonC.J. SpillerCalvin JohnsonArian FosterC.J. Spiller4.25
4Marshawn LynchTrent RichardsonJamaal CharlesJamaal CharlesArian Foster4.50
5Doug MartinCalvin JohnsonDoug MartinMarshawn LynchCalvin Johnson4.75
6Jamaal CharlesArian FosterC.J. SpillerC.J. SpillerJamaal Charles6.50
7Arian FosterRay RiceRay RiceTrent RichardsonMarshawn Lynch6.75
8LeSean McCoyLeSean McCoyMarshawn LynchCalvin JohnsonRay Rice9.00
9Dez BryantDez BryantAlfred MorrisLeSean McCoyLeSean McCoy9.50
10Alfred MorrisMarshawn LynchTrent RichardsonRay RiceTrent Richardson11.00
11Trent RichardsonA.J. GreenJimmy GrahamAlfred MorrisAlfred Morris11.50
12Ray RiceJamaal CharlesBrandon MarshallDez BryantDez Bryant13.75
13Jimmy GrahamDemaryius ThomasLeSean McCoyDrew BreesBrandon Marshall15.75
14A.J. GreenMaurice Jones-DrewA.J. GreenAaron RodgersJimmy Graham16.00
15Brandon MarshallJulio JonesMaurice Jones-DrewChris JohnsonA.J. Green16.00
16Julio JonesAlfred MorrisAaron RodgersPeyton ManningDemaryius Thomas17.75
17Matt ForteChris JohnsonDemaryius ThomasBrandon MarshallChris Johnson18.25
18Drew BreesMatt ForteChris JohnsonLarry FitzgeraldAaron Rodgers18.50
19Demaryius ThomasBrandon MarshallAndre JohnsonJulio JonesJulio Jones19.25
20Larry FitzgeraldJimmy GrahamLamar MillerJimmy GrahamLarry Fitzgerald20.00
21Aaron RodgersLamar MillerDrew BreesStevan RidleyDrew Brees21.25
22Stevan RidleyRoddy WhiteLarry FitzgeraldDemaryius ThomasMatt Forte21.50
23Chris JohnsonAaron RodgersSteven JacksonMatt ForteMaurice Jones-Drew22.00
24Roddy WhiteSteven JacksonCam NewtonLamar MillerSteven Jackson25.00
25Randall CobbStevan RidleyDez BryantA.J. GreenLamar Miller26.50
26David WilsonLarry FitzgeraldPeyton ManningSteven JacksonStevan Ridley26.75
27Steven JacksonDarren McFaddenJulio JonesMaurice Jones-DrewDavid Wilson29.25
28Victor CruzDeMarco MurrayMatt ForteMatt RyanReggie Bush30.00
29Cam NewtonDavid WilsonDavid WilsonVincent JacksonRoddy White30.25
30Reggie BushAndre JohnsonVictor CruzMontee BallAndre Johnson30.75
31Vincent JacksonDwayne BoweColin KaepernickVictor CruzCam Newton31.00
32Maurice Jones-DrewCam NewtonVernon DavisAndre JohnsonVictor Cruz31.75
33Hakeem NicksDrew BreesTom BradyDavid WilsonPeyton Manning32.00
34Montee BallLe'Veon BellRoddy WhiteDwayne BoweFrank Gore36.00
35Danny AmendolaFrank GoreDeMarco MurrayFrank GoreVincent Jackson36.75
36Jordy NelsonReggie BushFrank GoreLe'Veon BellDeMarco Murray38.00
37Peyton ManningTorrey SmithDanny AmendolaRandall CobbTorrey Smith39.00
38Frank GoreVictor CruzReggie BushReggie BushDwayne Bowe39.25
39Torrey SmithRandall CobbStevan RidleyCam NewtonRandall Cobb39.50
40Le'Veon BellRob GronkowskiMatt RyanRussell WilsonDanny Amendola39.75
41Lamar MillerMarques ColstonRob GronkowskiRoddy WhiteLe'Veon Bell40.00
42Andre JohnsonHakeem NicksVincent JacksonRyan MathewsMontee Ball42.50
43DeMarco MurrayDanny AmendolaDarren McFaddenDarren McFaddenDarren McFadden43.00
44Vernon DavisMontee BallDwayne BoweDanny AmendolaMatt Ryan44.50
45Marques ColstonVincent JacksonRyan MathewsEddie LacyHakeem Nicks46.50
46Antonio BrownAhmad BradshawLe'Veon BellDeMarco MurrayRob Gronkowski47.00
47Eddie LacyJordy NelsonEddie LacyRob GronkowskiEddie Lacy47.50
48Dwayne BoweRyan MathewsWes WelkerTom BradyMarques Colston48.50
49Pierre GarconPeyton ManningRobert GriffinRashard MendenhallVernon Davis48.75
50Colin KaepernickMike WallaceJason WittenMike WallaceTom Brady49.00
51Russell WilsonEddie LacyAhmad BradshawJordy NelsonRyan Mathews49.75
52Matt RyanRashard MendenhallMarques ColstonAndrew LuckColin Kaepernick50.00
53Eric DeckerShane VereenRashard MendenhallMatthew StaffordJordy Nelson50.75
54Tavon AustinCecil ShortsHakeem NicksShane VereenMike Wallace54.00
55Mike WallaceAndrew LuckTorrey SmithDarren SprolesAndrew Luck56.00
56Robert GriffinVernon DavisJared CookMarques ColstonAhmad Bradshaw56.00
57Andrew LuckTom BradyRandall CobbHakeem NicksRussell Wilson58.25
58Tom BradyMatt RyanMatthew StaffordJames JonesMatthew Stafford59.50
59Darren McFaddenMike WilliamsEric DeckerAhmad BradshawRashard Mendenhall60.00
60Rob GronkowskiEric DeckerAndrew LuckCecil ShortsDarren Sproles61.00
61Darren SprolesAndre BrownMike WallaceBryce BrownRobert Griffin62.50
62Steve SmithMatthew StaffordMontee BallChris IvoryEric Decker63.00
63Giovani BernardColin KaepernickTony GonzalezVernon DavisShane Vereen63.25
64Ryan MathewsPierre GarconMark IngramTorrey SmithCecil Shorts64.50
65Matthew StaffordDeSean JacksonCecil ShortsBenJarvus Green-Ellis Pierre Garcon65.75
66James JonesJosh GordonJosh GordonReggie WayneAntonio Brown66.00
67Reggie WayneSteve JohnsonAndre BrownWes WelkerWes Welker67.00
68Ahmad BradshawTony RomoShane VereenTony GonzalezJames Jones69.75
69Tony RomoRussell WilsonJordy NelsonGolden TateSteve Johnson70.00
70Steve JohnsonDaryl RichardsonAntonio BrownTony RomoMark Ingram71.00
71Mark IngramGiovani BernardMike WilliamsRobert GriffinTony Gonzalez71.00
72Jason WittenLaMichael JamesJames JonesJason WittenTony Romo71.75
73Tony GonzalezAntonio BrownRussell WilsonT.Y. HiltonJason Witten72.00
74DeSean JacksonRobert GriffinSteve JohnsonPierre GarconGiovani Bernard73.75
75Wes WelkerMark IngramMichael VickAntonio BrownReggie Wayne75.25
76T.Y. HiltonBryce BrownPierre GarconMichael FloydDeSean Jackson77.50
77DeAngelo WilliamsSteve SmithDaryl RichardsonVick BallardDaryl Richardson77.75
78Shane VereenWes WelkerDeSean JacksonMikel LeshoureMike Williams78.75
79Cecil ShortsKenny BrittGiovani BernardSteve SmithSteve Smith79.50
80Daryl RichardsonTony GonzalezTony RomoEric DeckerPierre Thomas81.00
81Pierre ThomasJason WittenGreg OlsenMark IngramAndre Brown82.00
82Andre BrownBenJarvus Green-Ellis Denarius MooreGiovani BernardBryce Brown83.75
83Jermichael FinleyJames JonesReggie WayneAndre BrownT.Y. Hilton84.25
84Miles AustinAnquan BoldinEli ManningDaryl RichardsonKenny Britt86.25
85Kenny BrittReggie WayneAlex SmithAnquan BoldinJosh Gordon87.00
86Rashard MendenhallTavon AustinAnquan BoldinMiles AustinChristopher Ivory88.00
87Greg JenningsDarren SprolesJonathan StewartMike WilliamsTavon Austin88.25
88Christopher IvoryMikel LeshoureChris IvoryAndy DaltonAnquan Boldin88.50
89Denarius MooreLance MooreBen RoethlisbergerColin KaepernickDenarius Moore89.00
90Lance MooreDenarius MooreBen TateKenny BrittMiles Austin91.00
91Ben RoethlisbergerBernard PierceKenny BrittJosh GordonBen Roethlisberger91.00
92Eli ManningDeAngelo WilliamsAndy DaltonJermichael FinleyBenJarvus Green-Ellis 95.25
93Ronnie HillmanChris IvoryBryce BrownDeSean JacksonBen Tate95.50
94LaMichael JamesT.Y. HiltonT.Y. HiltonIsaiah PeadEli Manning96.00
95Bernard PierceBen TateSam BradfordGreg JenningsLaMichael James99.25
96Ben TateVincent BrownMiles AustinGreg OlsenLance Moore100.50
97Fred JacksonChris GivensJustin BlackmonDenarius MooreVincent Brown101.00
98Mike WilliamsMiles AustinLaMichael JamesLance MooreGreg Jennings102.25
99Anquan BoldinGreg OlsenFred DavisChris GivensMichael Floyd104.75
100Emmanuel SandersSidney RiceSteve SmithJonathan StewartAaron Dobson105.75
101Vincent BrownMichael FloydBenJarvus Green-Ellis Ben TatePhilip Rivers106.00
102Aaron DobsonJared CookCarson PalmerBernard PierceJared Cook107.00
103Johnathan FranklinEmmanuel SandersDarren SprolesTavon AustinGreg Olsen108.00
104Brandon LaFellEli ManningAaron DobsonEli ManningBernard Pierce108.75
105Bryce BrownDarrius Heyward-BeyBrandon MyersSteve JohnsonJermichael Finley109.00
106Philip RiversJonathan StewartJay CutlerAaron DobsonOwen Daniels109.00
107Jared CookGreg JenningsJohnathan FranklinDeAngelo WilliamsDeAngelo Williams110.00
108Greg OlsenJustin BlackmonKyle RudolphJohnathan FranklinChris Givens110.50
109Owen DanielsGolden TateVincent BrownJustin BlackmonMartellus Bennett111.00
110Coby FleenerRueben RandleTavon AustinPhilip RiversKyle Rudolph113.00
111Martellus BennettAaron DobsonFred JacksonJoseph RandleBrandon Pettigrew114.00
112Fred DavisKnile DavisJosh FreemanShonn GreeneFred Jackson114.25
113Kyle RudolphStepfan TaylorJermichael FinleyPierre ThomasAlex Smith115.00
114Brandon PettigrewChristine MichaelMichael FloydKyle RudolphKenbrell Thompkins117.00
115Alex SmithRyan BroylesIsaiah PeadCarson PalmerSidney Rice118.25
116Bilal PowellNick ToonRyan TannehillZac StacyEmmanuel Sanders119.00
117Kenbrell ThompkinsAlshon JefferyAntonio GatesSam BradfordGolden Tate120.00
118Josh BoyceJacquizz RodgersJonathan DwyerMartellus BennettJustin Blackmon120.50
119Sidney RiceMichael BushChris GivensAntonio GatesJohnathan Franklin121.00
120Golden TatePierre ThomasGreg JenningsSidney RiceMalcom Floyd121.00
121Malcom FloydDuJuan HarrisLatavius MurrayRyan BroylesJacquizz Rodgers122.00
122Jacquizz RodgersAntonio GatesMatt FlynnRobert WoodsAntonio Gates122.00
123Joe FlaccoRod StreaterBrandon PettigrewStepfan TaylorRonnie Hillman122.75
124Michael VickFred JacksonRyan BroylesCordarrelle PattersonJoe Flacco123.00
125Josh GordonCoby FleenerLance MooreFred JacksonMikel Leshoure124.00
126Jon BaldwinDeAndre HopkinsJon BaldwinJacquizz RodgersRyan Broyles125.00
127Chris GivensGreg LittleKendall WrightBrandon LaFellJon Baldwin126.00
128Michael FloydBrian HartlineJoe FlaccoDeAndre HopkinsAndy Dalton126.50
129Darrius Heyward-BeyDanny WoodheadRonnie HillmanBrandon MyersBrandon LaFell129.50
130Antonio GatesPhilip RiversEmmanuel SandersVincent BrownMichael Vick129.75
131Brandon MyersVick BallardBrian QuickJared CookBrandon Myers131.00
132Rueben RandleRonnie HillmanGreg LittleBilal PowellRueben Randle132.00
133BenJarvus Green-Ellis Zac StacyBrian HartlineLaMichael JamesDeAndre Hopkins132.00
134Stephen HillJoique BellSidney RiceRoy HeluCarson Palmer132.50
135DeAndre HopkinsKnowshon MorenoPhilip RiversMichael BushSam Bradford132.75
136Nick ToonMichael VickKnowshon MorenoKendall WrightBilal Powell134.25
137Steve BreastonShonn GreeneBrandon LaFellRonnie HillmanIsaiah Pead135.50
138EJ ManuelRashad JenningsPierre ThomasJonathan DwyerNick Toon136.00
139Christine MichaelJonathan DwyerDeAndre HopkinsBrian HartlineSteve Breaston137.00
140Ryan BroylesStephen HillRod StreaterRiley CooperFred Davis139.00
141Vick BallardAlex SmithJake LockerSantonio HolmesDarrius Heyward-Bey140.00
142Jermaine GreshamLatavius MurrayDwayne AllenMohamed SanuVick Ballard141.00
143Jonathan StewartBilal PowellMikel LeshoureEmmanuel SandersShonn Greene141.75
144Joseph RandleIsaiah PeadMohamed SanuRueben RandleJermaine Gresham142.00
145Ed DicksonKyle RudolphJake BallardRod StreaterJonathan Dwyer142.75
146Carson PalmerJermaine GreshamBilal PowellLeGarrette BlountJonathan Stewart143.00
147Matt SchaubRoy HeluBernard PierceJoique BellKendall Wright144.50
148Jay CutlerJermichael FinleyVick BallardIsaac RedmanRod Streater147.00
149Sam BradfordZach MillerAlshon JefferyRobert TurbinBrian Hartline147.50
150Andy DaltonBrandon LaFellMartellus BennettRob HouslerMichael Bush147.75
151Josh FreemanKeenan AllenJacquizz RodgersDustin KellerJosh Freeman149.00
152Alshon JefferyMohamed SanuRobert TurbinDarrius Heyward-BeyZac Stacy149.50
153Greg LittleToby GerhartBrandon WeedenGreg LittleKnowshon Moreno150.75
154Julian EdelmanOwen DanielsEJ ManuelAndre RobertsJay Cutler151.00
155Kendall WrightKendall HunterNate WashingtonJosh FreemanAlshon Jeffery152.00
156Nate WashingtonBrandon MyersOwen DanielsAlex SmithJoseph Randle152.75
157Nate BurlesonSantana MossSantana MossKenbrell ThompkinsCoby Fleener153.00
158Roy HeluJon BaldwinRashad JenningsKnowshon MorenoGreg Little153.00
159Shonn GreeneCordarrelle PattersonShonn GreeneRashad JenningsStepfan Taylor153.75
160Michael BushKendall WrightMalcom FloydBrandon PettigrewRoy Helu154.75
161Josh MorganRobert TurbinZac StacyAlshon JefferyChristine Michael157.25
162Jordan Cameron Daniel ThomasJermaine GreshamDanny WoodheadCordarrelle Patterson160.50
163Jake BallardRiley CooperCordarrelle PattersonFred DavisJordan Cameron 162.00
164Rob HouslerMike GoodsonDeAngelo WilliamsJermaine GreshamRyan Tannehill162.25
165Dwayne AllenDustin KellerRueben RandleDuJuan HarrisDanny Woodhead163.75
166Dustin KellerJohnathan FranklinZach MillerChristine MichaelRob Housler164.00
167Santonio HolmesCarson PalmerJoseph RandleCoby FleenerRobert Turbin164.00
168Justin BlackmonJay CutlerJacoby JonesBraylon EdwardsDustin Keller164.25
169Jake LockerMartellus BennettStepfan TaylorJason AvantDwayne Allen166.00
170Ryan TannehillSam BradfordMike GoodsonJacoby JonesRashad Jennings166.25
171Matt FlynnBrandon PettigrewChris PolkJulian EdelmanKnile Davis166.75
172Mohamed SanuDwayne AllenRobert WoodsKeenan AllenStephen Hill167.25
173Kendall HunterIsaac RedmanJacoby FordOwen DanielsEJ Manuel168.00
174Knowshon MorenoAndre RobertsDarrius Heyward-BeyJonas GrayAndre Roberts169.67
175Isaac RedmanDoug BaldwinDustin KellerDaniel ThomasRiley Cooper169.75
176Jonathan DwyerAndy DaltonTyler EifertJames StarksLatavius Murray170.75
177A.J. JenkinsBen RoethlisbergerMichael BushMalcom FloydMohamed Sanu172.00
178Keenan AllenJosh FreemanDanny WoodheadJeremy KerleyMatt Flynn172.25
179Jacoby FordAustin PettisEd DicksonEd DicksonJoique Bell175.25
180Rod StreaterRyan TannehillRoy HeluZach MillerZach Miller176.25
181Andre RobertsJosh BoyceNate BurlesonTyler EifertIsaac Redman176.50
182Montario HardestyFred DavisGolden TateJay CutlerDuJuan Harris176.50
183Knile DavisEJ ManuelA.J. JenkinsRyan TannehillKeenan Allen177.75
184Riley CooperRob HouslerKenbrell ThompkinsMichael VickEd Dickson178.25
185Geno SmithJacoby FordKnile DavisDwayne AllenMatt Schaub178.50
186Danny WoodheadMatt FlynnDexter McClusterBrent CelekNate Washington179.25
187Mikel LeshoureBrandon WeedenMatt SchaubKnile DavisJosh Boyce179.75
188Zac StacyMarcedes LewisBrandon LloydBen RoethlisbergerJake Ballard182.00
189Isaiah PeadJoseph RandleBrandon GibsonMatt SchaubSantonio Holmes182.00
190Brian HartlineJoe FlaccoTandon DossBrian QuickMontario Hardesty182.00
191Heath MillerMatt SchaubFelix JonesAustin PettisBrian Quick182.25
192Robert WoodsBrandon LloydRiley CooperJoe FlaccoJake Locker182.50
193Ryan WilliamsJarius WrightChristian PonderLeonard HankersonKendall Hunter183.00
194Robert TurbinJordan CameronDion LewisKendall HunterDaniel Thomas183.25
195Marcel ReeceJames StarksStephen HillDonald BrownJulian Edelman183.50
196Cordarrelle PattersonKenbrell ThompkinsAndrew HawkinsNate WashingtonSantana Moss183.50
197Daniel ThomasBraylon EdwardsQuinton PattonEJ ManuelJacoby Ford186.75
198Brian QuickDexter McClusterMarcedes LewisKenny StillsMike Goodson188.50
199Marcedes LewisJulian EdelmanDaniel ThomasDexter McClusterNate Burleson189.50
200Toby GerhartA.J. JenkinsPercy HarvinStephen HillJacoby Jones189.50


Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

Get Instant Access To This Article Get Access To This Article
RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only MLB Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire MLB fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Chris Liss
Chris Liss was RotoWire's Managing Editor and Host of RotoWire Fantasy Sports Today on Sirius XM radio from 2001-2022.
RotoWire Roundtable: 2025 Fantasy Baseball Top-300 Rankings
RotoWire Roundtable: 2025 Fantasy Baseball Top-300 Rankings
The Z Files: My New Approach to the Roundtable Rankings
The Z Files: My New Approach to the Roundtable Rankings
Farm Futures: Rookie Outfielder Rankings
Farm Futures: Rookie Outfielder Rankings
Offseason Deep Dives: Reynaldo Lopez
Offseason Deep Dives: Reynaldo Lopez